One of the most common strategies to-date for government agencies and higher education institutions to influence their vendors’ operational and supply chain practices is to request information from them on their sustainability practices as part of the bid solicitation. While these requests go by many different names (survey, scorecard, checklist or questionnaire), their purpose is to encourage vendors to improve their sustainability performance by asking them to disclose their efforts to reduce GHG emissions during the bid solicitation process. The questions asked by the organization may be the same for each solicitation, or they may be tailored to each bid in order to focus on where the largest sources of operational or supply chain impact are likely to occur within the contract.

Both vendors and purchasers face significant challenges to using questionnaires effectively. For purchasers, unless the data is verified by a third party, it is difficult to verify the responses provided by vendors. In addition, the general nature of many of the questions asked as part of a solicitation may not address the largest opportunity for impact reduction. From the vendor’s point of view, some vendors have reported a large increase in the number of solicitations requiring completion of sustainability questionnaires, each with their own unique format. This has required a shift in the vendor’s resource and time allocation towards completing these surveys rather than focusing on business sustainability. Lastly, in our research, we found that no public agencies requesting sustainability questionnaires from vendors were using this information beyond the bid evaluation to benchmark and measure vendor performance improvements, or engage in strategic partnerships to advance mutual sustainability goals.

However, our research identified some established and emerging best practices for utilizing surveys in contracting for professional services.

Action 6.1

Incorporate sustainability questionnaire into bid evaluation scoring

Professional services vendors may be motivated to improve their sustainability performance if these actions are scored as part of the bid evaluation in a best value bid solicitation. To do this, the purchaser requires bidders to answer specific sustainability questions and defines how those questions will be evaluated to receive points for bid scoring. Purchasers should consider how they will verify the bidders’ answers and require documentation, whenever possible.  See below for examples of how agencies are using sustainability questions in their competitive bid evaluations.

Case Study: Multnomah County, OR, sustainability questionnaire

Multnomah County, Oregon, focuses on the triple bottom line of sustainability; Environmental Considerations, Social Equity and Economic Impact. They seeks to conduct business with vendors who demonstrate responsible business practices through sustainable innovations and accordingly, they include vendor evaluation questions on responsible business practices of up to 25% of the bid evaluation points, a portion of which directly relate to environmental initiatives implemented by the vendor. Below is a link to a contracting example from Multnomah County.

Find out more at Multnomah County’s website.

 

Case Study: City of Vancouver, Canada corporate leadership questionnaire

The City of Vancouver, Canada uses a Supplier Code of Conduct to ensure all City vendors meet minimum requirements related to ethical, social and environmental standards. In addition, they recognize vendors that are demonstrating leadership and innovation in sustainability by asking vendors to complete a corporate leadership questionnaire. Completion of the questionnaire is required, and answers are evaluated as part of bid scoring as described in the bid document.

Find out more about Vancouver’s sustainable purchasing program at their website.

Action 6.2

Require use of standard assessment tools and centralized data repositories

In place of issuing unique supplier questionnaires, purchasers can ask or require a vendor to use established assessment tools and supplier performance data repositories.   This identifies    vendors who are committed to measuring their impacts. By utilizing existing resources, purchasers benefit by obtaining credible information from reputable sources, and vendors benefit by reducing the number of unique surveys they must complete. These repositories also have the benefit of collecting voluntary data from multiple suppliers, and in some cases, vendors can benchmark themselves against peers in their industry, thus allowing for competition to incentivize emissions reduction activities. The figure below lists possible sources for identifying supplier information related to their sustainability activities and operations.

Assessing supplier sustainability through centralized repositories

Organization Website
Global Reporting Initiative www.globalreporting.org
CDP www.cdp.net
Ceres www.ceres.org
Supply Shift www.supplyshift.net
EcoVadis www.ecovadis.com

This list is not exhaustive and inclusion does not confer endorsement. Those wishing to use this list should evaluate the certification to assess appropriateness for their situation.

Case Study: City of Cleveland, OH local and sustainable purchasing preference

In 2010, the City of Cleveland adopted a Local and Sustainable Purchasing ordinance document , which provides a 2-4% bid preference for companies that source products locally and/or are certified as a sustainable business. To be eligible as a sustainable business, companies must be headquartered in the 5 county region (Cuyahoga, Geauga, Lake, Lorain and Medina) and be certified as a sustainable business through approved programs, including the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI), Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP), or Green Plus.

Find out more about Cleveland’s sustainable purchasing program at the website.

Action 6.3

Use questionnaires as a benchmark for continuous improvement goals and metrics

Supplier questionnaires can be used as a starting point for continued engagement between the supplier and purchasing organization. The contract requirements can include ongoing contract reporting and continuous improvement goals that ensure high priority sustainability initiatives remain an integral part of the contract deliverables for the life of the contract.

The Federal GSA contract for Domestic Delivery Services includes two examples of ongoing engagement and reporting. First, the contract requires FedEx and UPS to report annually on actual GHG emissions associated with contract delivery use for each federal agency utilizing the contract. These reports allow agencies to manage their emissions related to their use of this contract. Second, it requires FedEx and UPS to report annually on continual improvement against contractor-provided goals for alternative fuel and vehicle use. These reports are then incorporated into the overall contract performance management reviews. For more information on how the Federal GSA implemented these strategy, check out this this factsheet.

Other metrics that may be appropriate to include as part of regular contract status reports are business miles traveled and transportation modes. Tracking this information over a contract life may incentivize increase use of virtual meeting strategies, or lower-carbon travel modes.

Action 6.4

Use questionnaires to inform future engagement efforts or contracting strategies

In some cases, questionnaires may be a valuable tool for gaining insights into areas ripe for collaboration within specific professional service sectors or to identify initiatives that can be included within contract requirements in future solicitations. These surveys should be specifically designed to gather the information required to move these initiatives forward.

Case Study: Nova Scotia sustainability assessment

Nova Scotia, Canada uses a Sustainability Assessment is to gather information and evaluate the sustainability of potential vendors. Completion of the assessment is required. The proponent sustainability assessment is an initiative for the government of Nova Scotia and is part of the overall implementation of the provincial Sustainable Procurement Policy.

Case Study: City of Portland, Oregon sustainable questions

The City of Portland, OR has a sustainable purchasing philosophy of thinking carefully about what they buy, buying only what is really need, purchasing products and services with high environmental performance and considering the social and economic impacts of a purchasing decision. The bid documents below highlight examples of environmental specification in professional services contracting that seek to engage vendors in achieving these goals. Find more examples at the Portland website.