Introduction

The production, use and disposal phases of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) equipment by the government sector has significant impacts on the environment through overall energy consumption and emissions of greenhouse gas emissions. The lifecycle of ICT hardware comprises several complex production stages, including acquisition of raw materials, manufacturing, transportation, distribution, use and maintenance, and end of life disposal.

Key climate impacts of purchases of ICT hardware result from both the use phase and upstream production phase:

  • Energy consumed during the use phase:
    • If all computers sold in the U.S. were ENERGY STAR certified, over $1 billion in energy costs would be saved yearly.  ENERGY STAR  is a U.S. Environmental Protection Agency voluntary program that helps governments, businesses and individuals save money and protect the climate through superior energy efficiency.  The program certifies products that meet ENERGY STAR standards for energy efficiency.
  • Greenhouse gases emitted:
    • If all computers sold in the U.S. were ENERGY STAR certified, approximately 15 billion fewer pounds of GHG emissions would be emitted, equivalent to more than 1.4 million vehicles being taken off the road.
  • Upstream (or embodied) energy:
    • Energy consumed during the acquisition of raw materials and manufacturing components is also highly significant.  This includes mining of metals such as copper, cobalt, gold, tin and aluminum which are highly energy intensive activities.
  • Other significant impacts of the ICT lifecycle:
    • Chemical and water usage in mining processes, plastics production, component manufacturing and end-of-life management.
    • Use of flame-retardant chemicals, which have endocrine disrupting effects, in the product.
    • Use of conflict minerals sourced from regions where armed conflict and human rights abuses occur related to mining activities.

Estimates project that government will increase use of ICT hardware dramatically over the next decades. The expansion of technology use means that energy consumption and other impacts of the sector will continue to rise.

Recommended Actions

Action 1.1: Make sure current agency hardware standards include the current ENERGY STAR standards.

Energy Star is an international program for encouraging and recognizing the most energy efficient products in the marketplace. ENERGY STAR qualified computers and other ICT equipment use energy efficient power supplies, operate efficiently in multiple modes of operation, and come equipped with power management features.  According to the EPA, in 2012, energy use in the U.S. associated with ENERGY STAR computers and monitors is 32 billion kWh per year less than it might have been without ENERGY STAR.

ENERGY STAR’s Low Carbon IT Campaign is a comprehensive, nationwide effort to help organizations take advantage of all the programs resources to significantly lower energy consumed by ICT equipment. It promotes three key strategies to reduce energy consumption and GHG from enterprise ICT equipment:

●      Choose Energy Efficient ICT Equipment: Organizations should require all products be certified to the current Energy Star standards. The program provides guidance on specifications and purchasing for computers, displays, small networking equipment, servers, VOIP phones, televisions, and uninterruptedly power supplies (UPS).When developing bid language, reference the language in the ENERGY STAR Product Purchasing & Procurement template letter. 

●      Enable power management systems that monitor and control activity levels of individual PC hardware components such as processors, batteries, AC adapters, fans, monitors and hard disk.The program provides a spreadsheet to estimate your PC power management savings. Check out how to Power Manage Computers, which covers how to activate sleep settings, the business case for power management, and how to calculate potential savings.

●      Reduce peripheral energy consumption: Encourage your ICT department to take the Low Carbon ICT Pledge. According to Energy Star, agencies have pledged over 7 million computers to power management, saving 2,786,806,470 lbs of GHGs avoided annually, and 1,815,509,101 kWh saved annually.

Action 1.2: Go Beyond Energy STAR ™

Go beyond ENERGY STAR by requesting comparative TEC data and award higher points to vendors offering equipment with higher TEC numbers. Alternatively, require that equipment has a 20% higher TEC than current ENERGY STAR standards.

Action 1.3: Purchase EPEAT registered computers, laptops, servers, printers, multifunction devices and other IT equipment:

EPEAT is an easy-to-use resource for identifying high-performance, environmentally preferable products. EPEAT is a voluntary registry covering desktops, notebooks, monitors, imaging equipment and televisions, which may be registered at the gold, silver or bronze level. EPEAT incorporates the current ENERGY STAR standards as they are updated and also addresses the full life cycle, including toxics. You can use the EPEAT registry to find products which meet key toxics reduction criteria.

Hundreds of businesses, schools, hotels, hospitals and governments around the world use EPEAT to help them make informed purchasing decisions.

EPEAT is based on the IEEE 1680 family of Environmental Assessment Standards. This includes the “umbrella standard,” which describes how products are registered by declaring their compliance to specific criteria, how they are rated based on the criteria they meet, how registration by country operates and how product declarations are verified. The related product standards 1680.1, 1680.2, and 1680.3 contain the specific criteria for “PCs and PC Displays,” “Imaging Equipment,” and “Televisions,” respectively, upon which EPEAT registration and ratings are currently base

View Sample Contract Language from dozens of state governments, municipal jurisdictions, higher education and other organizations here

Action 1.4: Extend the life of IT hardware

A key procurement strategy to reduce the GHG emission footprint of your ICTC equipment is to extend the life of the equipment, which effectively reduces demand.   By not purchasing as much new equipment, the embodied energy or upstream emissions embedded in ICT hardware purchases is lowered dramatically.  There are a few strategies here:

  • Implement longer replacement cycles, also known as product duty or refresh cycles, for ICT equipment.  Many agencies refresh equipment every four to five years, compared to the former standard of three years. Also consider cycling older equipment to different agency uses when buying new equipment.
  • Consider upgrading power-hungry components to more efficient versions. In particular, older graphics cards used in many workstations and high-end desktops can consume nearly as much power as the computer itself. Newer graphics cards can use half the electricity, and increase performance, while avoiding the embodied carbon emissions associated with replacing the entire computer.
  • Purchase ICT equipment that is designed for longevity.  Request comparable data from vendors on design for upgradeability, and reparability and durability.  Award higher points to vendors offering better design options.
  • Select a vendor that offers robust technical support to ensure that equipment is operated and maintained for highest energy efficiency.
  • Train ICT staff on proper maintenance, which is a critical element in operating ICT equipment for energy efficiency.  Temperature, dust, misuse and fluctuating electrical supplies can all have detrimental impacts on the functioning and energy efficiency of ICT equipment.

The European Commission Green Public Procurement (GPP) program has published helpful EU GPP criteria for maximizing energy efficiency through extending the life of equipment, including requirements that:

  • Memory is readily available and can be changed or upgraded.
  • Hard drive and CD/DVD drives can be changed.
  • Training and user support for green management of ICT equipment is available.
  • Energy management functions are present.
  • Parts for repair and upgradeability are available for at least three years.
  • Additional points are awarded for easier disassembly and recycling.

Important things to consider:

  • Warranty terms
  • Planning for turnover management
  • It is important to think about the function desired in relation to the purchase. See ENERGY STAR.
  • Is there any data on how to pencil out the GHG benefits of new hardware outweigh holding on to old items?
  • Toxics reduction:
    • ENERGY STAR ITC products must meet the standards of the ROHS regulations. The ROHS Directive aims to restrict the use of certain hazardous substances. It also bans placing new electrical and electronic equipment on the European Union market if it contains more than the agreed-upon levels of hazardous materials such as lead, cadmium, mercury, hexavalent chromium, and flame retardants.
    • Use the EPEAT registry to find products which meet several toxics reduction criteria.
  • Packaging reduction and smart delivery systems will reduce the amount of GHG in the upstream phase.
  • Social responsibility: see TCO Development Report on The State of Socially Responsible Manufacturing in the IT Industry. http://tcodevelopment.com/news/the-state-of-socially-responsible-manufacturing-in-the-it-industry/
  • Percent of post-consumer recycled content in plastics.

Cost considerations

Energy efficient IT equipment is generally price neutral, i.e. there is little to no price impact from buying the more efficient products. Significant financial gains can be achieved due to reduced energy consumption over the lifecycle of energy efficient ITC products. See the ENERGY STAR website for calculator. Applying a total cost of ownership approach when awarding a contract will ensure that financial costs are minimized. According to the EU GPP report, total cost of ownership variables for ITC equipment include: usage behavior, repair costs, on-site management, and shifting market trends affecting pricing. Note that organizations are often structured so that the department paying for the IT equipment is not paying for the energy consumption of that equipment.

Purchasing results