Action 3.1
Some infrastructure or building projects specify SCM minimums to reduce the carbon impacts of the mix. Examples include the following:
- Seattle Department of Transportation (SDOT) specifying that all sidewalks be constructed with a minimum of 25% SCM (Tracy, 2014 ‘add citation”).
- California’s High Speed Rail project also specifies minimum SCM for specific applications (cite http://www.hsr.ca.gov/docs/programs/construction/RFP_B4-PtC1_StandrdSpecification.pdf).
Minimum SCM specifications opens up a potential perception that the owner is starting to specify means and methods. With that comes a potential liability if mix designs meeting a target do not perform as expected (Sound Transit, December 2014). Although the risk of liability seems quite low, it is still a valid consideration when writing specifications. Another downside of minimum SCM specifications is that the carbon savings are not actually quantified. As expected, with higher the SCM percentages, the carbon impact of the mix is reduced. However, without quantifying business as usual compared to the low carbon mixes, governments may have a difficult time tracking the carbon savings that result from their purchases. In an era of increasingly important Climate Action Plans, quantifying carbon savings is an important factor.
Action 3.2
Some governments create maximum SCM limits for various uses of concrete through their construction specifications. This can be a limiting factor when trying to create lower carbon mixes, sometimes called “lean” mixes, which have higher SCM percentages. Use of fly ash and slag are often capped at percentages that are lower that what the literature suggests is feasible, and also in some cases at percentages that are lower than caps put in place by the state agencies, as is the case shown in the table below for the Seattle Department of Transportation (SDOT) and the Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) (Tracy, 2014; Sound Transit, 2014, A.6). Even with these lower-than-necessary limits, most projects are replacing cement at well below the allowable maximum. The table below shows the results of a survey of over 15 different SDOT and WSDOT projects. As the table below makes clear, actual cement replacements are in most cases not reaching allowable maximums.

A report prepared for Sound Transit Authority identified 4 primary reasons that the actual SCM percentages achieved in the table above fall below the allowable maximums:
- Concern around schedule delays due to the longer set times for high SCM concrete
- A lack of compelling financial incentives that would offset the negative impact to the schedule
- Lack of priority for public agencies and lack of encouragement for contractors to achieve the max allowances already in specifications
- Lack of minimum SCM allows mixes to be in compliance w/o any SCM content. When minimums do exist, however, there is little incentive to ever exceed the minimum which stifles further advancement.
Action 3.3
Overall, the use of compelling incentives can leave the mix design to the concrete supplier and contractor while still motivating project teams to propose mix designs that reduce cement. Government purchasers should consider meaningful incentives in markets that have less familiarity with SCM or markets that are meeting bare minimum SCM targets.
The Seattle Department of Transportation used to incentivize the reduction of cement content per cubic yard of concrete in road pavement through 2012 (Tracy, 2014; Sound Transit, 2014). They did this by setting cement maximums per class of material, then calculating a per pound incentive for each pound reduced in the mix below the maximum cement content. Overall, SDOT staff report that while the program did achieve GHG savings, the incentives were small compared to the total value of the construction contract. While the incentive was a factor to move toward lower cement mixes, it was likely not the prime motivation (Sound Transit, Dec 2014).
