Reward Companies/Vendors that have EPDs during the bidding process with extra points.
Ready mix concrete EPDs all follow the same product category rules (PCR) so they can be comparable to one another. Product category rules are the accounting and reporting rules for EPDs. There are many efforts underway, especially in the building products realm, to ensure increased comparability of EPDs in the future. Nevertheless, governments should be cautioned about selecting a concrete producer solely on the basis of comparing their EPD to another company. Instead, a good interim step would be to reward companies that have EPDs during the bidding process with extra points. That said, once a specific concrete producer is selected, the EPDs produced for mixes from an individual plant are very comparable to one another. This is because EPDs from the same concrete plant are all using the same background data to produce their EPDs. Thus, it’s very reasonable to compare a standard mix design to a low carbon mix design from the same plant and have high confidence in the carbon reductions documented in the EPDs.
As government purchasers, asking for EPDs will not only signal the market that the impacts of producing building materials is important but will also allow purchasers to make measurable and substantial reductions in the carbon impacts of their purchases.
The green building market is starting to demand EPDs across the spectrum of building products. The US Green Building Council’s LEED building rating system is the most widely used green building rating system for commercial buildings in North America. Version 4 of the LEED standard, which becomes mandatory for projects registering for certification after October 2016, is now rewarding points to products with EPDs and even more points to products that can show how their EPD has lower impacts compared to the industry average EPD for that product category. The result of this dramatic change in the LEED rating system is that many building product manufacturers are aggressively pursuing EPDs for their products. Besides the quantified disclosure benefits for the purchaser, the EPD will also serve as a baseline for improvement for the producer of that product.
Action 1.2
Request or require Environmental Product Declarations (EPDs) that show a % reduction below the National Ready Mix Concrete Association’s (NRMCA) regional benchmarks.
NRMCA is the national industry association for ready mix concrete producers. As a service to their members, NRMCA produced a national average EPD by surveying their members about the impacts of the production practices. This proactive strategy allows individual concrete producers to compare their plant specific EPDs to the regional or national averages for various mix strengths. Since NRMCA reports the average, one would expect half the producers in a region to be above the average and half to be below. Therefore, to encourage the selection of concrete mixes that perform better than the regional averages, government purchasers could request or require concrete bids to show a percent improvement below the regional averages for a given material class. For example, a government could request that EPDs submitted for a project show a 20% reduction of carbon impacts compared to the regional benchmarks. The big advantage of this approach is that it is performance based rather than prescriptive specifications. Performance based specifications allow for the most flexibility and creativity of the contractor to meet those specifications compared to the minimum and maximum SCM approaches described below.
NRMCA’s industry average EPD can be found here:
http://www.nrmca.org/sustainability/EPDProgram/Downloads/NRMCA%20EPD%2012.07.2014.pdf
NRMCA’s regional benchmark mixes can be found here:
